A Fallen Hero - Video Inside

It doesn't seem fair to have the city's examiner deliberate on a case that could cost the city billions of dollars.

If Hirsch wants a future working for the city, he has to come up with a conclusion like this.
 
simuvac said:
It doesn't seem fair to have the city's examiner deliberate on a case that could cost the city billions of dollars.

If Hirsch wants a future working for the city, he has to come up with a conclusion like this.
Good point, I never looked at it like that...
 
Friends Come To The Aid Of 9/11 First Responder

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21502164/

10/27/2007

BARNEGAT TOWNSHIP, N.J. - A fundraiser was held Friday night to help a man who used to make a living helping others.
Images

The Jersey Shore resident was one of the first responders to the attacks at the World Trade Center on Sept. 11, 2001. But as NBC 10?s Doug Shimell explained, these days, he's in need of a helping hand himself.

"This is not about me. This is about all the 9/11 first responders and rescue workers. Those of us that are sick and dying. We just want our dignity,? Charlie Giles said.

Giles, a former N.Y. EMT, can't work due to lung problems caused by the dust and debris at ground zero. The 9/11 Victims? Fund hasn't paid his medical bills and his Barnegat Township, N.J., home is in foreclosure. For those reasons, colleagues and local officials went to work to help Giles out. It has become a rescue mission for the rescuer.

"If the president and the national government, you know, the federal government would just step in, take a look at this and let's get something going for these people," Barnegat Township Mayor Al Cirulli said.

Ailing New York firefighter Billy Maher also came. In Michael Moore's documentary, "Sicko," Maher was flown to Cuba for medical treatment.

"We're all in this together. We're kind of like standing alone right now. We're fighting for all of us," Maher said.

Students from the Kenneth R. Olson Middle School in Tabernacle, N.J., raised nearly $800 for Charlie.

"We didn't think we'd raise that much money. We were just so excited when we found out. We were blown away by how generous people were," said one student.

But when John Feal arrived, Giles became emotional. Feal lost a foot as a 9/11 responder at ground zero. He is the founder of Feal Good Foundation and has adopted Giles? case.

"We're going to show the federal government that while they sit idle that people like us that really have nothing after 9/11, can still make a difference and help," Feal said.

Those who came to the fundraiser brought a donation. In the end, the amount totaled $5,000. The sum brought Giles to tears, once again.
 
Error halts auction of 9-11 EMT's property

http://www.pressofatlanticcity.com/top_three/story/7512515p-7410909c.html

By EMILY PREVITI Staff Writer
Published: Saturday, October 27, 2007

BARGNEGAT TOWNSHIP - Friday was kind to Charlie Giles.

The sheriff's auction of his home, scheduled for Tuesday, was postponed until Nov. 13, Ocean County Undersheriff Wayne Rupert confirmed late that afternoon.

That evening, about 100 firefighters, police officers, activists, local leaders and friends of the Giles family gathered at the Pinewood Estates Fire-house on Route 72 to watch Giles receive $3,500 to help pay his medical expenses from the FealGood Foundation, the Barnegat Police Benevolent Association and We Are Change.

At one point during the ceremony, Giles sobbed.

"Six years I have been waiting for help from our government," he said. "The FealGood Foundation came into my life last Sunday. And in six days, more has happened to my family and myself than has happened in six years."

Giles, 39, responded on Sept. 11, 2001, as an emergency medical technician. He moved with his family to Barnegat in 2002. Since then, the family's financial situation has grown dire because of medical expenses related to his 9-11 response. In March, Giles received a foreclosure notice.

He has attributed his financial situation to bureaucratic red tape involving the New York State Crime Victims Board and New York State Workers' Compensation Board. The latter office cannot discuss cases without the written permission of the individual. Giles declined to give permission on the advice of his attorney, Sean Riordan of FealGood.

Riordan and the group's founder John Feal attended the event Friday night in Barnegat.

Feal lauded the recent response to Giles' plight, an unfortunate situation which, he pointed out, is not unique among Sept. 11 responders. In the past two months, Feal estimated Riordan, an attorney specializing in workers' compensation, had added 66 cases to his load, including Giles'. Riordan has taken Giles' case pro bono.

While the donations and support garnered for Giles have come courtesy of the community, the delay of the sale of his home was likely prompted by a filing or typographical error.

Wachovia Bank apparently was incorrectly named as the plaintiff in the foreclosure suits, according to the bank's in-house counsel Mark Farmer and Jerry Dasti, a lawyer for Giles.

"They don't know who holds the mortgage," Dasti said. "I expect to get that on Monday. It's my hope that we can tie this thing up one way or another next week.

Giles' mortgage is through Americas Servicing Company. However, Wachovia had sold the package of loans containing Giles' mortgage in 2005, according to spokesperson Don Vecchiarello. Dasti, Farmer and Americas Servicing Company executives have been trying since Monday to figure out how the mix-up happened.

Kevin Waetke, communications manager for Wells Fargo Home & Consumer Finance Group, the parent company of Americas Servicing Company, said the company incorrectly assigned the trustee.

"Obviously, there was some mess up on the other end," Dasti said. "I received a call late this afternoon from Americas Servicing Company. They're going to provide a proposal next week … and a solution to try to resolve it."

The law firm representing the plaintiff - Phelan, Hallinan & Schmieg LLP, which has offices in Mount Laurel and Philadelphia - has not returned repeated calls for comment.

Not everyone in the community has expressed support without question. Bernard Laufgas, of Barnegat, was one who questioned Giles' credentials and claims of Sept. 11 response. Laufgas also took issue with Giles' "using" the event to gain financial support.

"If he was there, God bless him," Laufgas said.

Court records show that Laufgas filed a lawsuit in 2006 against Giles and two of his running mates in a school board election for placing signs on property Laufgas owned.

The Press of Atlantic City obtained medical records that verify Giles' response to Ground Zero, and confirmed it with his employer at the time, Warren Golden, chief operating officer of Citywide Emergency Mobile Response Corp. The Press also has seen Giles' badge and certification.

"I have two weeks of breathing room to find out who owns my house," Giles said. "Hopefully my attorney can get something happening and worker's comp … or somebody comes through to help me."

To e-mail Emily Previti at The Press: [email protected]
 
Outpouring of help for afflicted 9/11 EMT
But he still faces losing his home

http://www.app.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20071028/NEWS02/710280446/1070

BY MATT PAIS
MANAHAWKIN BUREAU
Posted by the Asbury Park Press on 10/28/07

BARNEGAT — Charlie Giles has fallen on tough times, but those close to him are hoping to band together and rescue the 9/11 responder from financial ruin.

Giles — a certified emergency medical technician who responded to the World Trade Center as a supervisor with CityWide EMS and then returned to the site as a volunteer for two months — has been unable to work because of a series of health problems he says are related to breathing hazardous dust.

Now, crushed by the weight of medical bills, he's fallen behind on his mortgage and foreclosure proceedings are under way. The Ocean County Sheriff's Department is scheduled to auction off the home on Tuesday.

"Times are tough," Giles said.

The financial trouble for the 40-year-old Giles, his wife and two daughters has snowballed as his medical condition has worsened, he says. There have been more than a dozen trips to the hospital, piles of medication, a hip-replacement operation and pending knee reconstruction — the latter two procedures attributed to prolonged steroid use made necessary by a diminished lung capacity.

He's had to bear much of the cost for the procedures himself, with little income aside from the $241.57 weekly stipend he receives for disability. He has encountered a tangle of red tape while trying to claim disability, worker's compensation and crime-victim benefits he says he's entitled to.

Now, he hopes a last-ditch fundraising effort will be enough to help save his home.

"We've gotten a lot of help from a lot of people, and we'll see what happens," he said.

Among those lending the biggest hand are Giles' brethren at the Pinewood Estates Volunteer Fire Co., which he joined after moving to Barnegat six years ago. The company has raised more than $5,000 through a benefit account it established at Commerce Bank and through other fundraisers.

"He's an awesome guy and he's got a big heart. We're trying to do everything we can to help him out," said company member Mike Essig.

Foundation assistance
The efforts received a big boost this week when a published report about his struggles caught the eye of John Feal, a 9/11 responder who heads the FealGood Foundation — a nonprofit organization dedicated to spreading awareness about the disaster's long-term health effects on those who worked at the World Trade Center.

"In 2001, on Sept. 11, everybody was patriotic and everybody wanted to help. I hope I can resurface some of those feelings," Feal said. "You don't need a plane to hit a building to be compassionate."

Feal, who has helped dozens of other responders, began a massive public-relations campaign on Giles' behalf, including appearances on Star Jones' CourtTV show and CBS news.

He drummed up more than $2,000 in a few days, drawing donations from unlikely sources, including more than $100 from elementary school students in Purchase, N.Y.

"These were 10- and 11-year-olds doing what they can, and, meanwhile, our federal and state government sits by while more and more people die," Feal said.

As part of his foundation, Feal has advocated for the release of funding to help the estimated 30,000 responders suffering from 9/11-attack-related physical and mental illnesses.

"There are thousands of Charlie Gileses out there," he said.

In addition to raising money to save the Giles family home, Feal has found an attorney experienced with 9/11 workers' rights to handle Giles' government claims pro bono. While any government check is undoubtedly too far away to arrive in time for Tuesday's deadline, Feal said he hopes the attention drawn to Giles will spur more support for others in need.

"People like Charlie Giles can't move on because they don't have justice," he said. "The government needs to do more; that's the bottom line."
 
Again, Bloomberg called insensitive for 9/11-related remark

http://www.silive.com/newsflash/metro/index.ssf?/base/news-29/1193808853289220.xml&storylist=simetro

By SARA KUGLER
The Associated Press
10/31/2007, 1:17 a.m. EDT

NEW YORK (AP) — When Mayor Michael Bloomberg ignited a fury by saying a deceased police detective who worked on the World Trade Center cleanup was "not a hero" because of questions about the cause of his death, he found himself in a familiar place.

Bloomberg, a businessman who favors data and numbers over the touchy-feely side of governing, often lands in hot water when talking about issues related to the aftermath of the Sept. 11 disaster.

In his first year as mayor, shortly after the attack, he angered victims' relatives when he said he favored a "less is more" approach to the memorial. And when he said downtown residents wouldn't want to live next to a "cemetery," it made things worse.

The next year, during a meeting at City Hall, he upset Diane and Kurt Horning, who lost their son in the attack and were furious that the city buried sifted trade center dust in a Staten Island landfill.

Diane Horning says Bloomberg was "dismissive and abrupt" about their views on grieving and remains, and implied that he doesn't personally identify with their cause because he plans to donate his body to science.

Bloomberg's aides and associates say it is simply not his style to emote and dwell on the past, and that he has a more forward-looking approach, which can come across as cold and matter-of-fact.

In the latest confrontation, Zadroga's family and the city's police unions called for an apology from the mayor, saying his comment was heartless. They said every member of the police force is a hero for putting their lives on the line, particularly those who worked in the months-long cleanup at ground zero.

Speaking Monday to students at Harvard University, where he was accepting a public health award, Bloomberg was asked about the idea of applying hard science to public policy. In his answer, he brought up Chief Medical Examiner Charles Hirsch's recent conclusion that Zadroga's fatal lung disease was not from trade center dust but because he had been injecting himself with ground-up pills.

"Nobody wanted to hear that — we wanted to have a hero and there are plenty of heroes," Bloomberg said. "It's just, in this case, science says this was not a hero."

"A nice human being, a tragic death, all of that is true," he added.

Zadroga's family disputes Hirsch's findings about drug use; a New Jersey medical examiner ruled separately last year that Zadroga died from inhaling the toxic ground zero dust. He put in more than 400 hours at ground zero, and his death at 34 made him a symbol of ailing Sept. 11 workers around the country.

The family sought Hirsch's opinion as part of the city's required process to include additional names on the official Sept. 11 victims list and memorial wall to be built at ground zero.

"The mayor is a political person, he's acting on a political agenda — to me, he's heartless, he has no compassion whatsoever for people and their lives and their families," said the detective's father, Joseph Zadroga. "He just doesn't understand what integrity means, what getting your name on the wall means, what getting a medal means, what honor and duty is."

Detectives' Endowment Association President Michael Palladino said the police force had lost faith in the mayor and City Hall, and that Bloomberg's comments stung the hundreds of rescue workers who say they have become sickened after working on the cleanup.

"Hirsch's findings and the mayor's comments are an insult to the families of those first responders who made the ultimate sacrifice, like Jimmy Zadroga, and all those other first responders that are still suffering with the illness of 9/11," Palladino said.

At a news conference in Brooklyn, Bloomberg backpedaled carefully, praising the detective for his "impressive record," saying he didn't mean to upset anyone. He declined to say whether he regrets the remark about Zadroga not being a hero.

"This was a great NYPD officer who dedicated himself, put his life in harm's way hundreds of times during his career, and you can use your own definition — I think it's a question of how you want to define what a hero is," Bloomberg said. "And certainly I did not mean to hurt the family or impugn his reputation."

Joseph Zadroga said he would like to meet with the mayor to explain the family's view of the detective's death, and Bloomberg spokesman Stu Loeser said he would be happy to do so.

The family has released more than 100 pages of medical records that showed Zadroga developed breathing problems just after the 2001 attacks.

Zadroga's father says the medicine his son was taking to treat his illness — including several strong painkillers and anti-anxiety pills — were never improperly injected.

Bloomberg's comments were "just heartbreaking, and my wife and my family just could not get over it," Joseph Zadroga said.
 
Fury After Bloomberg Says 9/11 Cop Not A Hero
Family Demands Apology From Mayor

http://wcbstv.com/topstories/james.zadroga.michael.2.470432.html

10/31/2007

NEW YORK (AP) ― A fury erupted today over Mayor Michael Bloomberg's remarks that police detective James Zadroga, who worked hundreds of hours at ground zero cleanup, is "not a hero" because his death was ruled unrelated to the toxic debris.

At a news conference in Brooklyn today, Bloomberg praised Zadroga for his "impressive record," and said he didn't mean to upset anyone.

The Zadroga family and the city's police unions has called for an apology from the mayor.

Speaking to students at Harvard University yesterday, Bloomberg was asked about the idea of applying hard science to public policy.

His answer brought up Chief Medical Examiner Charles Hirsch's recent conclusion that Zadroga's fatal lung disease wasn't from trade center dust but from injections of ground-up pills. The mayor added "science says this was not a hero."

Zadroga's family disputes Hirsch's findings; a New Jersey medical examiner ruled separately last year that Zadroga died from inhaling the toxic ground zero dust.
 
‘My son is a hero’
Parents of fallen cop blast Bloomberg

http://ny.metro.us/metro/local/article/My_son_is_a_hero/10541.html

by joshua rhett miller / metro new york
OCT 31, 2007

MANHATTAN. The family of a fallen NYPD detective and the city’s police unions demanded an apology yesterday from Mayor Michael Bloomberg for saying James Zadroga was “not a hero” because his death was ruled unrelated to toxic Ground Zero debris.

“I’m so upset about this,” Zadroga’s mother, Linda, told Metro yesterday. “New York killed my son and now it’s killing me.”

Linda Zadroga said she disputes Chief Medical Examiner Charles Hirsh’s finding that her son’s fatal lung disease did not stem from 400-plus hours at Ground Zero but because he had been injecting himself with ground-up pills. “My son was not on drugs,” she said. “My son is a hero.”

Bloomberg, speaking at Harvard University on Monday, relayed Hirsh’s findings when asked about applying hard science to public policy.

“It’s just, in this case, science says this was not a hero,” the mayor said. “A nice human being, a tragic death, all of that is true.”

A New Jersey medical examiner ruled last year that Zadroga died in January 2006 at age 34 from inhaling toxic dust, making him a symbol of ailing 9/11 rescue workers. Zadroga’s family then sought Hirsh’s opinion so he could be included in the city’s official Sept. 11 victims list and forthcoming memorial.

“We could care less about money,” Linda Zadroga said. “We want our granddaughter to know her father was a hero. We don’t want her to hear that her father was a drug addict, which he wasn’t.”

Detectives’ Endowment Association President Michael Palladino said his constituents had lost faith in Bloomberg and that his comments were an insult to hundreds of rescue workers who say they have become ill since their time on the pile. “I urge the mayor to publicly apologize to Zadroga’s family and his workforce,” Palladino said.

Meanwhile, Bloomberg yesterday praised Zadroga.

“This was a great NYPD officer who dedicated himself, put his life in harm’s way hundreds of times during his career, and you can use your own definition — I think it’s a question of how you want to define what a hero is,” he said. “And certainly I did not mean to hurt the family or impugn his reputation.”
 
Mayor Backs Away From Questioning Dead Officer’s Heroism

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/31/nyregion/31hero.html?ref=nyregion

By DIANE CARDWELL
Published: October 31, 2007

Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg backed away yesterday from his earlier statements that James Zadroga, a police detective who worked for hundreds of hours on the smoldering pile at ground zero, was “not a hero” because the city’s chief medical examiner ruled his death was not directly related to dust from the trade center site.

Go to City Room » “This was a great N.Y.P.D. officer who dedicated himself — put his life in harm’s way hundreds of times during his career — and you can use your own definition,” Mr. Bloomberg said at a news conference in Brooklyn when asked if he regretted his earlier comments. “It’s a question of how you want to define what a hero is, and certainly I did not mean to hurt the family or impugn his reputation.”

A New Jersey pathologist concluded in 2006 that Mr. Zadroga’s death was directly related to his work at ground zero, but New York City’s chief medical examiner, Dr. Charles S. Hirsch, recently rejected that finding. He concluded that it was misuse of prescription medication, not World Trade Center dust, that caused the detective’s lung ailments.

The tone of Mr. Bloomberg’s comments yesterday veered sharply from statements he made on Monday after receiving an award from the Harvard School of Public Health. Asked why science could be unpopular, he said that it sometimes provided answers that people did not want to hear, as in the case of Mr. Zadroga. Referring to Dr. Hirsch’s finding, he said, “Nobody wanted to hear that.”

“We wanted to have a hero, and there are plenty of heroes,” he said. “It’s just in this case, science says this was not a hero.”

Yesterday, Mr. Bloomberg described Detective Zadroga as “a dedicated police officer” with an impressive record who “volunteered to work downtown, and I think that the odds are that he clearly got sick because of breathing the air — but that’s up to the doctors.”

That did little to assuage Mr. Zadroga’s family, their lawyer, Michael Barasch, said. He said that the only thing that would satisfy the family was an apology and adding Mr. Zadroga’s name to the official list of 9/11 victims, which Mr. Bloomberg said he would not seek to do because of Dr. Hirsch’s ruling.
 
A Little History On James Zadroga

Saying James Zadroga isn’t a hero is like saying Michael Boomberg isn’t the mayor, George Bush isn’t the president, and Christine Todd Whitman never lied. The sad fact is all three are true, and all three have played a part in the death of a NYPD hero, and countless others. In closing, science says Bush has no brains Bloomberg has no heart, and Whitman has no regard towards human life. - John Feal


By Jon Gold
10/31/2007

On 1/7/2006, it was reported that "a police detective has died from lung disease, which the NYPD believes he contracted while working at Ground Zero after the 9/11 attacks." [...] "The tragedy makes James Zadroga, 34, the first rescue worker to die from illness attributed to the Ground Zero rubble, a police spokesperson said yesterday." [...] "He was a hero, he disregarded his own health and life to rescue people at Ground Zero," said Michael Palladino, head of the Detectives' Endowment Association."

On 4/12/2006, the Zadroga family released the findings of the NJ Medical Examiner. It said, "It is felt with a reasonable degree of medical certainty that the cause of death in this case was directly related to the 9/11 incident," wrote Gerard Breton, a pathologist at the Ocean County (New Jersey) medical examiner's office in the February 28 autopsy."

On 10/1/2007, it was reported that "the U.S. 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, which sits in Manhattan, will hear oral arguments today on whether the city is immune from lawsuits brought by the thousands of firefighters, police officers, and construction workers who searched for survivors and cleaned up on the site of the World Trade Center." After hearing the oral arguments, the three judges on the panel decided that they would let the law suits go through.

On 10/16/2007, it was reported that "New York City is willing to enter discussions to settle a lawsuit with 9,000 rescue and cleanup workers at the World Trade Center disaster site who may be sick from inhaling toxic dust."

On 10/17/2007, it was reported that "with about 9,000 claimants, the average payout would be some $66,000 per worker, not nearly enough to cover medical bills and lost wages, particularly in the case of deaths." That meant that the settlement probably wasn't going to be accepted, and the trials were going to go ahead. Which meant that the money they might pay out would be staggering compared to the settlement.

On 10/19/2007, after being asked by Joseph Zadroga, James Zadroga's father, to verify the NJ Medical Examiner's findings so Joseph would be listed as a victim of 9/11, Dr. Charles Hirsch, the NY Medical Examiner said that "it is our unequivocal opinion, with certainty beyond doubt, that the foreign material in your son's lungs did not get there as the result of inhaling dust at the World Trade Center or elsewhere." [...] "Mayor Michael Bloomberg distanced himself from the medical examiner's office in a statement Thursday, saying the independent agency made its own decisions. The city is defending itself in a lawsuit filed by thousands of workers who say they were not properly protected from the dust that made them sick. Bloomberg has also lobbied the federal government for millions of dollars to treat and monitor the ailing workers. The medical examiner's "determination in this case does nothing to change New York City's commitment to make sure that all who were affected by 9/11 get the health care they need," Bloomberg said."

On 10/23/2007, it was reported that the NY Medical Examiner's claim was that James Zadroga died from "intravenous drug injections." Essentially saying that James Zadroga was a junky, and that's why he died.

On 10/25/2007, it was reported that, "Joseph Zadroga said the former detective was taking more than a dozen medications when he died, including anti-anxiety medicine and painkillers including OxyContin, but never ground up pills and injected them. He said he kept his son's medication locked in a safe in their New Jersey home and said his son was not capable of taking medicine himself. "His mother and I were taking care of him," Joseph Zadroga said. "He wasn't ever able to correctly take his medication."

On 10/25/2007, it was reported that, "the New York City Medical Examiner concluded last week that the foreign matter found in Zadroga's lungs definitely did not come from dust generated at the World Trade Center site. That conclusion will create extra hurdles for lawmakers trying to get the federal government to pay for treatment for ailing Ground Zero workers."

On 10/26/2007, it was reported that, "Zadroga died despite excellent medical care, and his autopsy found that his lungs were filled with substances that hung in the air over The Pile. Among them, carbon, silica, calcium phosphate - found in concrete - talc and cellulose. The New Jersey medical examiner who autopsied Zadroga concluded the toxins destroyed his lungs. Dr. Michael Baden, a former city chief medical examiner who is now the state police forensic pathologist, reviewed and confirmed the autopsy findings."

Finally, it was reported, like the Bush Administration has parroted its' "intelligence" in order to "catapult the propaganda", and after "distancing" himself from the NY Medical Examiner's office, Mayor Michael Bloomberg parroted the findings of Charles Hirsch by saying said, “We wanted to have a hero, and there are plenty of heroes,” he said. “It’s just in this case, science says this was not a hero.”

I gotta tell ya. Some days, it's very hard to be non-violent. No, that DOES NOT mean I condone violence. Just trying to point out how angry this makes me.
 
zadrogapoll.gif


http://news.aol.com/story/_a/is-dead-new-york-city-cop-a-hero/20071101062709990001?ncid=NWS00010000000001
 
Mayor To Meet With Detective Zadroga's Family

http://www.ny1.com/ny1/content/index.jsp?stid=3&aid=75167

October 31, 2007

Mayor Michael Bloomberg will meet with the family of James Zadroga Monday, several days after taking heat for some comments he made about the detective.

The meeting is scheduled for Monday afternoon at City Hall.

Earlier this week, the mayor said former NYPD Detective James Zadroga, who worked on the September 11th recovery efforts at the World Trade Center site, wasn't a hero. But, he later called him a great officer and said he didn't mean to cast doubts on his reputation.

The mayor's comments prompted Zadroga's father to say Bloomberg was heartless and mean-spirited.

A New Jersey medical examiner ruled Zadroga'a death was directly related to the time he spent working at the WTC site. However, the city's M.E. said he contracted lung disease by injecting ground up pills into his system and not from breathing in toxins at the site.
 
Parents of WTC cop to Mike: You're wrong, our son's a hero

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/2007/11/04/2007-11-04_parents_of_wtc_cop_to_mike_youre_wrong_o.html

BY PATRICE O'SHAUGHNESSY
DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER
Sunday, November 4th 2007, 10:37 AM

Joseph Zadroga considered the two stunning twists in the saga of his dead son and weighed which was the more painful.

Was it the meeting at the city morgue, where Chief Medical Examiner Charles Hirsch told the family in dry, scientific terms that James Zadroga, a decorated detective, died because he misused prescription drugs - not from inhaling toxic dust at Ground Zero?

Or was it Mayor Bloomberg publicly declaring that Hirsch's findings prove Zadroga, who became a worldwide symbol of the insidious health damage of 9/11, was not a hero?

"What Hirsch said really hurt. I knew it wasn't true," Joseph Zadroga said. "He disgraced my son's and my family's reputation, to say not just he was misusing drugs, but he was an intravenous drug user."

Then Zadroga shook his head and his eyes saddened.

"When Bloomberg said that, I said, 'I don't friggin' believe this.'"

All the Zadrogas have wanted for more than five years is for their son to be acknowledged as a 9/11 hero.

"It would be nice for his baby," said James' mother, Linda Zadroga, speaking of her orphaned granddaughter. "It would mean something for her."

The torment that has consumed the Zadroga family since their Jimmy took ill in 2002 did not end when he died last year. It was extended by the findings of two pathologists - that inhaled dust from Ground Zero killed him, and then by the shocking ruling by Hirsch.

Joseph Zadroga sat last week in the kitchen of the spacious gray shingled house in Little Egg Harbor on the Jersey Shore that the three generations of Zadrogas called home, his eyes scanning the panoramic view of Winding Creek and Great Bay, with Atlantic City rising in the distance.

He said he is absolutely positive there was no drug abuse.

"Jimmy had an intravenous line. I was giving him strong antibiotics through it," Zadroga said, pointing to crook of his elbow. "We doled out the other medication. He had short-term memory loss and would forget to take them, and we were afraid he would overdose.

"He had a pain-management doctor, he was getting eight tablets of OxyContin a day and 12 other medications."

A retired police chief of North Arlington, in Bergen County, Zadroga, 60, has a shaved head, gravelly voice and is powerfully built, as his son was.

He opened the 1,200-pound gray iron Liberty safe in a closet in his bedroom, where he keeps his guns and where he stored his son's medicines.

"He was on powerful stuff. We wanted to keep them from the baby," he explained.

Zadroga's eyes well up when he tells of caring for his son, who moved back with his parents in 2004 because he was sick and his wife had died suddenly. He had a toddler daughter to care for.

"He had two bags of antibiotics a day, it took 45 minutes for them to drip in," Zadroga said. "It became quality time for us. We sat and talked. Most of the rest of the time he'd be sleeping. I'm glad we had that time."

James Zadroga died at 34 on Jan. 5, 2006. His father found him on the floor. He had gotten up to get milk for his daughter - the cup was in his hand.

Dr. Gerard Breton, Ocean County medical examiner, did an autopsy and consulted with Armed Forces Institute of Pathology and Dr. Michael Baden, a renowned expert in forensic pathology.

The Armed Forces Institute said Zadroga's lungs had talc, cellulose, methacrylate and calcium phosphate, carbon and silica. Breton concluded Zadroga died of severe scarring of lung tissue and said the cause of death was directly related to 9/11.

It was the first link established between a Ground Zero worker's death and exposure to the dust there. James Zadroga became the face of post-9/11 illness, and Congress passed bills named for him to fund treatment for ailing Ground Zero workers.

Zadroga's family then asked Hirsch to review his death. They wanted his sacrifice documented by the city.

Hirsch studied slides of Zadroga's lung tissue. Hirsch also reviewed the military pathologist's report, but he didn't look at Zadroga's medical records, the detective's father said.

When the Zadrogas met two weeks ago with Hirsch, they brought along James Zadroga's young daughter Tyler-Ann. She sat in the room with her grandparents and watched as Joseph Zadroga propped a photo of her father, robust and slightly smiling in his blue NYPD uniform, on the table between them and Hirsch.

"Hirsch never looked at it," Joseph Zadroga recalled.

The longtime medical examiner told the family he had concluded James Zadroga had ground up his medication and injected the drugs into his bloodstream, leaving traces of the pills in his lung tissue.

The talc and cellulose found in the lung tissue are often binding agents in pills and capsules.

Linda Zadroga became so upset after Hirsch gave them the news that she bolted from the room. Her granddaughter followed.

"She saw how upset I was, and she was trying to comfort me," Linda Zadroga said.

In their grief, the family believes Hirsch's decision is part of a campaign to deny that their son's death is related to 9/11. They say the campaign included the feds or the city pressuring doctors and hospitals to deny their son care, and harassment from the NYPD, with police helicopters flying over their house.

"They don't want to open the floodgates" to all the others sickened at Ground Zero, Joseph Zadroga said.

Baden, the doctor who had consulted previously with the New Jersey medical examiner, disagrees with Hirsch's findings.

Baden said the materials in James Zadroga's lungs are found in concrete and wood. Baden noted he also saw large glass fibers, plastic and other materials that would have come from toxic dust. He said the material was primarily in the airways and concluded the particles were inhaled, not injected.

Joseph Zadroga has a 4-inch-thick blue binder of his son's medical records, letters to and from elected officials, doctors and lawyers. A biopsy photo of his son's lungs shows a black mass.

James Zadroga and his daughter lived on the second floor of the house, which has a remarkable fireplace fashioned like a sand castle, with two turreted towers forming the mantle.

Prominently displayed are a cross made from World Trade Center metal, a replica of Zadroga's gold detective shield, No. 6663, and photos of Tyler-Ann, who turned 6 Thursday. Zadroga's parents are raising the girl.

James Zadroga had surprised his father when he joined the NYPD. He was appointed in 1994, worked in Greenwich Village, Harlem, the Bronx, and in the street crime unit when it was an elite citywide unit. His last command was the Manhattan South homicide squad.

His police record aside from his 9/11 duty would be enough to deem him a hero cop: He amassed 187 arrests - 136 of them felonies - and earned 38 citations.

"He never told us about them," the father said.

Zadroga grew up in North Arlington, played football in high school, went to Bergen Community College and loved to hang out across the Hudson River. He later wrote about "the two towers that I grew up with when I looked out my back door."

He developed the "World Trade Center cough" soon after the attack on the skyscrapers. James Zadroga spent 400 hours at the rubble, according to the NYPD.

It's going on two years, but Linda Zadroga hasn't cleaned out her son's room.

"I can't go up there," she said. "I made it to the landing, and I came back down the stairs."

Like many parents of cops and firefighters killed on 9/11, the Zadrogas wear symbols of their pain and loss.

The mother wears a silver heart with a photo of her dead son and the words "Jimmy 9/11 Hero." Her husband has a large tattoo on his forearm of the Ground Zero cross and his son's shield.

"Everyone praises the dead as heroes as they should, but there are more living suffering than dead," James Zadroga himself wrote a year after 9/11, when illness gripped him.

Since declaring Zadroga was not a hero, Bloomberg has tempered his remarks, calling the detective a dedicated cop. But it did not assuage the outrage from the family and the city detectives union, so Bloomberg has invited the Zadrogas to City Hall tomorrow.

"I've been asking to meet with him since '02," said Joseph Zadroga. "I hope he publicly apologizes."
 
Bloomberg Sorry for 'Not a Hero' Remark

http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5gedchpIl6oM7F3AwCEyXaLDuYMzgD8SNODOG0

12 minutes ago

NEW YORK (AP) — A week after saying a ground zero worker was "not a hero" because drugs were found to have caused his death, Mayor Michael Bloomberg apologized to the man's father Monday.

After meeting with the mayor at City Hall, Joseph Zadroga said Bloomberg also told him he was going to try to find a way for the Sept. 11 victims memorial to include those who have been sickened by the toxic ground zero dust and debris.

Bloomberg drew outrage with his reaction to Chief Medical Examiner Charles Hirsch's recent conclusion that Zadroga's son, James, contracted a fatal lung disease not from the World Trade Center dust he inhaled for weeks, but by injecting himself with ground-up pills.

"We wanted to have a hero," Bloomberg said Oct. 29. "There are plenty of heroes. It's just that in this case, the science says this was not a hero."

The family of James Zadroga, a retired police detective, rejects allegations that the 34-year-old took any medications improperly. At least two other medical experts have concluded that the material found in his respiratory system included microscopic shards of debris from the terrorist attacks on Sept. 11, 2001.

The mayor backpedaled after saying Zadroga was not a hero, calling him "a great NYPD officer" who had repeatedly risked his life for the city and had gotten sick from breathing contaminated air at ground zero. He said, however, that it would be up to the public to decide whether Zadroga was a hero.

Hirsch's ruling meant the police detective would not be included on the official list of victims and his name would not be etched on the memorial wall. So far, only one person who survived the towers' collapse but died later of health problems has been added to the official death toll.
 
Mayor sorry for calling Ground Zero cop 'not a hero'

http://www.newsday.com/news/local/newyork/ny-nyzero06,0,7946098.story

BY KARLA SCHUSTER | [email protected]
3:48 PM EST, November 5, 2007

A week after he said a police detective who died after working at Ground Zero was "not a hero", Mayor Michael Bloomberg apologized to man's father on Monday, and promised that the city will find a way to memorialize rescue and recovery workers who died after being exposed to dust while working at the former World Trade Center site.

"The mayor apologized for his statement, the mayor was very gracious, he showed sympathy for James, he said James was a true hero, that he was just misquoted or taken out of context when he said what he said," said Joe Zadroga, father of detective James Zadroga, after a 35-minute meeting with Bloomberg Monday afternoon at City Hall.

Zadroga also said that the mayor, who heads the board of the National Sept. 11 Museum and Memorial at the World Trade Center, vowed to figure out a way to include those who worked at Ground Zero after the Sept. 11 attacks and were exposed to and sickened by toxic dust. "He understands that the people that are passing away after, such as Jimmy, and that he will go back to the (World Trade committee and figure out some way, that somehow they will come up with a way of recognizing these people that are passing away from their illnesses from the World Trade Center."

Det. James Zadroga, 34, who worked hundreds of hours at Ground Zero after the terrorist attacks, became a symbol of post-Sept. 11 illness after his death last year. The meeting came after the mayor, speaking in Boston last week, said that Zadroga was not a hero, referring to a ruling by the city's chief medical examiner, Dr. Charles Hirsch, that the detective's death was not a result of exposure to toxic trade center dust. Instead, Hirsch said that Zadroga's fatal lung disease resulted from Zadroga injecting himself with ground-up pills.

The conclusion contradicted a previous pathologist's report that said Zadroga's death was the result of his work after the 2001 terrorist attacks.

"We wanted to have a hero. There are plenty of heroes. It's just that in this case, the science says this was not a hero," Bloomberg said last Monday. But at yesterday's meeting, the mayor had a different take, according to Michael Barash, the Zadrogas' attorney.

"The mayor said 'you know - it mayor told them that it seems clear that his illness and disability were caused by World Trade Center exposure,' " Barash said. "The mayor seemed open-minded to us...We appreciate the fact that he's willing to have this looked at again by Dr. Hirsch and we're hoping we can win the battle. Who says you can't fight City Hall?"
 
Mayor Bloomberg apologizes to WTC cop's family

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/2007/11/05/2007-11-05_mayor_bloomberg_apologizes_to_wtc_cops_f.html

DAILY NEWS STAFF
Monday, November 5th 2007, 3:00 PM

Mayor Michael Bloomberg has apologized for saying that a police detective who died after working at Ground Zero "was not a hero," the cop's dad said Monday.

James Zadroga, 34, died in January of a lung disease. Chief Medical Examiner Charles Hirsch recently concluded his illness was not caused by dust from the World Trade Center site, but rather by injecting himself with ground-up pills.

The ruling meant the police detective would not be included on the official list of victims and his name would not be etched on the 9/11 memorial wall.

Zadroga's father, Joseph, met Monday with the mayor at City Hall. The father said Bloomberg apologized for saying the ruling meant his son was "not a hero" and said he would try to find a way for the Sept. 11 victims memorial to include those who have been sickened by the toxic debris at Ground Zero.
 
9/11 responder laid to rest in Hauppauge

http://www.news12.com/LI/topstories/article?id=202753

(11/09/07) HAUPPAUGE - A New York City police sergeant who worked at ground zero was laid to rest in Hauppauge Friday after losing an 18-month battle with cancer.

Michael Ryan, of Hauppauge, was 41 years old when he passed away Monday. He was 39 when doctors diagnosed him with three different aggressive types of cancer.

Ryan spent hours working at ground zero and a Staten Island landfill after the Sept. 11 attacks. During that time, he inhaled dangerous toxins many believe directly caused hundreds of emergency workers to develop cancer and other ailments.

Ed Mullins, of the NYPD Sergeants Benevolent Association, said he will continue to fight for health care for the group that considers itself forgotten by the city it served. Ryan's funeral, held at Saint Thomas More Church in Hauppauge, was not conducted as an "in the line of duty" death, which Mullins said makes all the difference.

"There's a significant difference between this becoming a line-of-duty death and a non-line-of-duty death, as far as pensions go and benefits go," Mullins said. "The truth of it is he was a 39-year-old healthy individual involved in athletics, and two years later, at the age of 41, he's dead and it doesn't make sense."

Ryan, a 20-year police veteran, leaves behind his wife and four young children.

Neither New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg nor Police Commissioner Ray Kelly were in attendance for the funeral.
 
Back
Top